Clay County
Buttered Cookie Co

Buttered Cookie Co

Sweets & Treats in Green Cove Springs

5.0 4 Google reviews$1–40

+1 904 609 89 94203 Walburg St, Green Cove Springs, Florida 32043

Buttered Cookie CoButtered Cookie Co, photo 2Buttered Cookie Co, photo 3

Where to find them

203 Walburg St, Green Cove Springs, Florida 32043

Free newsletter

More of Green Cove Springs in your inbox

Local news, new businesses and what's on from What's Good Clay, once a week.

Get directionsOpen in Maps

About

Welcome to Buttered Cookie Co.! We are a local Cottage, home-based cookie company that specializes in clean ingredient, organic, and all natural baked goods. All baked goods are made-to-order tailored, specifically for your needs. How We Work: Because every order is handcrafted/custom-made, we operate on an order-by-order basis rather than traditional storefront hours. We accept private orders and regularly pop up at local markets on weekends, and host Saturday cookie drops! Getting in Touch: We are available most days via text, phone, or email to answer questions, discuss custom requests, and take new orders. Call or message us today to discuss your project or place an order!

What people say

5 out of 5 stars

“Hands down the best cookies I have ever had. Perfect texture, perfect taste, perfection all the way around. I use to think crumbl cookie has the best… I was wrong by far! BUTTERED COOKIE CO. Is the place to go!”
Google review · Sep 2026

5 out of 5 stars

“All of these cookies are amazing!!! If you haven't tried them yet you definitely should. The fluffy goodness and amazing flavor of each cookie will have you wanting more.”
Google review · Sep 2026

5 out of 5 stars

“Amazing!!!! Glorious!!!!! Delicious!!!!! You need to try these!!!! They are simply the best!!!! Will be ordering again!!!!”
Google review · Sep 2026

More Sweets & Treats in Clay County

Haven Sourdough Bakery
Haven Sourdough is a bakery in Green Cove Springs.
Sweet ol’ Nick Bakery
Founded by a professional chef with over a decade of culinary experience, Sweet ol Nick’s provides expertly crafted, love-filled baked goods that bring joy back to life’s celebrations. After my daughter’s Celiac diagnosis, I used my background to bridge the gap between strict allergen safety and exceptional flavor. To guarantee absolute safety, our workspace has been meticulously sterilized, operating as a 100% gluten-free kitchen with zero risk of cross-contamination. We understand food anxiety deeply and have engineered recipes so authentic in texture and taste they would fool traditional bakers. Our mission is simple: ensuring no one ever feels left out. Enjoy total piece of mind with every bite!
Walmart Supercenter Bakery
Shop your local Walmart for a wide selection of items in electronics, home furniture & appliances, toys, clothing, baby gear, video games, and more - helping you save money and live better.
Fresh Market Bakery Bakery
Fresh Market Bakery is a bakery in Fleming Island.
Fran’s Cookies Bakery
Fran's Cookies makes fresh, homemade custom cookies for every occasion, including holidays, birthdays, graduations, anniversaries, and more.
Carbivore Cafe LLc Bakery
Carbivore Cafe LLc is a bakery in Green Cove Springs.
The Baker’s Classroom Bakery
The Baker’s Classroom is a bakery in Green Cove Springs.
Walmart Neighborhood Market Bakery
Shop your local Walmart for a wide selection of items in electronics, home furniture & appliances, toys, clothing, baby gear, video games, and more - helping you save money and live better.

Is this your business? Free, takes two minutes.

What's Good Clay


© 2026 What's Good Clay.

What’s Good Clay is your guide to the good stuff happening across Clay County, from Fleming Island and Orange Park to Green Cove Springs, Lake Asbury, Middleburg, Oakleaf, and beyond. We find the local events, places to eat, things to do, community stories, and businesses worth knowing about, then put the best of it in one place.

© 2026 What's Good Clay.