Clay County
Your Pie Pizza

Your Pie Pizza

Sweets & Treats in Fleming Island

4.5 760 Google reviews$10–20

+1 904 375 97 711545 County Rd 220 Ste. 125, Fleming Island, Florida 32003

Your Pie PizzaYour Pie Pizza, photo 2Your Pie Pizza, photo 3Your Pie Pizza, photo 4

Where to find them

1545 County Rd 220 Ste. 125, Fleming Island, Florida 32003

Free newsletter

More of Fleming Island in your inbox

Local news, new businesses and what's on from What's Good Clay, once a week.

Get directionsOpen in Maps

About

Welcome to Your Pie Pizza in Fleming Island, where we specialize in crafting hand-tossed, brick-oven pizzas tailored to your taste. Our menu features a variety of options including vegan, vegetarian, gluten-free, and keto-friendly choices, alongside classic pizzas, savory wings, and hearty pasta dishes. Experience the convenience of curbside pickup, delivery, or enjoy our outdoor seating for a delightful dine-in experience. Your Pie Pizza is your destination for a family-friendly atmosphere and a diverse selection of Italian-inspired cuisine. We also provide catering in Fleming Island for events, office lunches, and gatherings of all sizes.

Amenities

From the business

  • Identifies as veteran-owned

Service options

  • Outdoor seating
  • No-contact delivery
  • Delivery
  • Onsite services
  • Takeout
  • Dine-in

Highlights

  • Fast service

Popular for

  • Lunch
  • Dinner
  • Solo dining

Accessibility

  • Wheelchair accessible entrance
  • Wheelchair accessible parking lot
  • Wheelchair accessible restroom
  • Wheelchair accessible seating

Offerings

  • Alcohol
  • Beer
  • Comfort food
  • Happy hour drinks
  • Quick bite
  • Small plates
  • Vegan options
  • Vegetarian options

What people say

5 out of 5 stars

“⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ 5 Stars — A Masterpiece of Sweet Heat and Italian Craftsmanship! Magnifico! This is not merely a pizza; it is a celebration of everything a great pie should aspire to be. The Hot Honey Pepperoni Pizza strikes a magnificent balance between the savory richness of beautifully charred pepperoni, the creamy indulgence of melted cheese, and the fiery sweetness of hot honey that dances across the palate like a perfectly conducted Italian symphony. The crust is a triumph in its own right: golden, rustic, and delightfully crisp on the outside, with a tender, satisfying chew within. The fresh basil adds an aromatic brightness, while the jalapeños provide a lively kick that complements rather than overwhelms the other ingredients. And that hot honey? Madonna mia! It ties everything together with a sweet, spicy finish that leaves you reaching for another slice before you’ve even finished the first. Every bite delivers layers of flavor—smoky, savory, spicy, sweet, and unmistakably indulgent. This is the sort of pizza that would make a Neapolitan grandmother pause mid-bite, nod approvingly, and pour another glass of wine. Verdict: Five stars without hesitation. A glorious marriage of Italian tradition and modern culinary audacity. If you appreciate a pizza that respects its roots while daring to be extraordinary, this hot honey pepperoni pie is an absolute must. Bravissimo! Una pizza fantastica! 🍕🇮🇹”
Google review · Oct 2026

5 out of 5 stars

“Came here years ago and tried it out with the new owners , OH MY GOSH!!! The black and blue with steak , Gorgonzola cheese, sauteed onions , and homemade garlic aioli sauce 🤤!!!! The fire roasted wings didn’t get pics because we ate them tooo fast !!! Dessert was the bourbon butter pecan gelato 😍”
Google review · Oct 2026

1 out of 5 stars

“Use to be my favorite place to eat...Last couple of visits...my pizza is burnt. Will definitely be finding a new pizza place.”
Google review · Oct 2026

Hours

Wednesday
11 AM to 8:30 PM
Thursday
11 AM to 8:30 PM
Friday
11 AM to 9 PM
Saturday
11 AM to 9 PM
Sunday
11 AM to 8:30 PM
Monday
11 AM to 8:30 PM
Tuesday
11 AM to 8:30 PM

More Sweets & Treats in Clay County

Cold Stone Creamery Ice cream shop
Your local Cold Stone Creamery in Fleming Island, FL is the ultimate ice cream shop offering Create Your Own Creations™ mixed on a granite slab, custom ice cream cakes for any occasion, and rich, creamy milkshakes. Indulge in endless flavors, mix-ins, and sweet treats made fresh just for you. Spring just got sweeter with two new Signature Creations™. Try Lemon Berry Batter and The Berry Best S’More, featuring bright lemon and sweet strawberry marshmallow flavors.
Jeremiah's Italian Ice Ice cream shop
Jeremiah's Italian Ice scoops up refreshing Italian Ice, creamy Soft Ice Cream, and their indulgent signature Gelati - the perfect layering of Ice and Soft Ice Cream. Jeremiah's hand makes their tasty frozen desserts daily, and offers free samples to ensure every guest has a flavorful experience. With more than 40 delicious flavor options, ranging from Mango to Cookies and Cream, including diary-free and vegan friendly options, there's a treat to fulfill any craving! Drop by to Live Life to the Coolest with the Jeremiah's Frog Squad!
Maggie D’s Ice Cream Ice cream shop
We are unique ice cream shop. We have hand dipped ice cream and soft serve ice cream. We make her own waffle cones homemade every day and waffle bowls. We also make brownies for a brownie sundaes every day. We make chocolate chip cookies homemade every day or a cookie sandwiches. We have banana splits, milkshakes, ice cream cones and waffle cones and bowls homemade. If you can dream it, we can make it. We set ourselves apart from the competition. We have homemade ice cream cakes, chocolate dipped bananas and brownie pops. These are all made homemade and fresh. Please come and visit and I promise we will be your favorite ice cream shop for you and your family!
Dairy Queen Grill & Chill Ice cream shop
Soft-serve ice cream & signature shakes top the menu at this classic burger & fries fast-food chain.
Dreamette Orange Park Ice cream shop
We are serving sweet soft serve Ice Cream in the beautiful town of Orange Park. We are located one block from the St Johns River. Dreamette, your happy place since 1948.
Swirl Suites Ice cream shop
Swirl Suites Rolled Ice Cream offers creamy, indulgent, creative rolled ice cream bowls. Traditional, premium hand scooped ice cream is also available. Swirl Suites offers handmade waffle cones, bubble egg waffles, croffles and poffertjes made to order. Other frozen dessert options including ice cream nachos, banana splits, milkshakes, sundaes and smoothies. Our rolled ice cream is prepared with premium ingredients and made to order, offering a fun, personalized, engaging experience for those who visit the creamery. Swirl Suites Rolled Ice Cream is Orange Park's original rolled ice cream shop serving the Jacksonville, Fleming Island, Middleburg and Orange Park areas. Come experience the difference and let us serve you.
Sweet J’s Creamery Ice cream shop
Sweet J’s Creamery is Green Cove Springs’ favorite spot for delicious ice cream, milkshakes, slushes, and more! Locally owned and operated, we serve up classic flavors, creative combos, and seasonal treats like our famous pumpkin pie and peppermint shakes. Whether you’re stopping by for a family outing, a quick sweet treat, or a fun dessert night, our friendly team is here to make your day a little sweeter. Enjoy high-quality ingredients, generous portions, and a welcoming, community-focused atmosphere. Visit us today and discover your new favorite ice cream shop!
McDonald's Ice cream shop
McDonald’s USA, LLC, serves a variety of menu options made with quality ingredients to millions of customers every day. Ninety-five percent of McDonald’s approximately 13,500 U.S. restaurants are owned and operated by independent business owners. For more information, visit www.mcdonalds.com, and follow us on social: X, Instagram, TikTok and Facebook.

Is this your business? Free, takes two minutes.

What's Good Clay


© 2026 What's Good Clay.

What’s Good Clay is your guide to the good stuff happening across Clay County, from Fleming Island and Orange Park to Green Cove Springs, Lake Asbury, Middleburg, Oakleaf, and beyond. We find the local events, places to eat, things to do, community stories, and businesses worth knowing about, then put the best of it in one place.

© 2026 What's Good Clay.